Top Items:
Lyle Denniston / SCOTUSblog:
Don't call it a mandate — it's a tax (UPDATED) — UPDATED to 12:50 p.m. For those reading the opinions, the key section on the mandate is in Roberts' opinion, from pp. 33-44. That clearly has five votes behind it. — Salvaging the idea that Congress did have the power to try …
Discussion:
The Huffington Post, The Daily Caller, The Hill, American Power, 2012 Decoded, Slate, Guardian, Althouse, Maggie's Farm, Bangor Daily News, Wake up America, Scared Monkeys, Angry Bear, Bookworm Room, Jack & Jill Politics, Taylor Marsh, The Moderate Voice, FiveThirtyEight and Capital Tonight, more at Mediagazer »
RELATED:
Jake Sherman / Politico:
Pence likens health care ruling to 9/11 — In a closed door House GOP meeting Thursday, Indiana congressman and gubernatorial candidate Mike Pence likened the Supreme Court's ruling upholding the Democratic health care law to the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, according to several sources present.
Discussion:
ThinkProgress, Mediaite, Mish's Global Economic …, The Maddow Blog and Guardian
Jennifer Haberkorn / Politico:
Health care ruling: Individual mandate upheld by Supreme Court — The Supreme Court upheld most of President Barack Obama's health care law Thursday, ruling that Congress did not overstep its power by requiring nearly all Americans to buy health insurance. — Chief Justice John Roberts joined …
Tim Mak / Politico:
Blog chatter: Impeach Roberts — Furious conservative activists lashed out Thursday in the blogosphere at Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts for siding with the left and upholding the individual mandate in “Obamacare,” with some even calling for his impeachment.
Discussion:
Alan Colmes' Liberaland, Patterico's Pontifications, Townhall.com, National Review, Hot Air and Daily Kos
John Hood / National Review:
The Mandate As Tax — Chief John Roberts may have flinched from doing what his fellow Republican-appointed justices were willing to do — strike down the individual mandate as a violation of the Commerce Clause — but he did so in a clever way. He resurrected an earlier argument …
Discussion:
Hot Air, Washington Monthly, The New Republic and The Spectacle Blog
Tom Scocca / Slate:
Obama Wins the Battle, Roberts Wins the War — The chief justice's canny move to uphold the Affordable Care Act while gutting the Commerce Clause. — There were two battles being fought in the Supreme Court over the Affordable Care Act. Chief Justice John Roberts—and Justice Anthony Kennedy …
Discussion:
Salon, Legal Theory Blog, ThinkProgress, protein wisdom, The Daily Beast, Gawker and The Daily Caller
Eric Kleefeld / Livewire:
DeMint: ‘Obamacare’ Still Unconstitutional — States Should Refuse To Implement It — Sen. Jim DeMint (R-SC) called on states to outright refuse to implement health care reform in the wake of the Supreme Court's decision upholding the law — which would amount to nullification by states.
Discussion:
ThinkProgress, Washington Monthly, United States Senator …, Talking Points Memo and Firedoglake
Dylan Byers / Politico:
CNN, Fox blow the Supreme Court ruling — In a rush to break the news, both CNN and Fox News inaccurately reported this morning's Supreme Court ruling on healthcare. — On television, on its website, and in breaking news alerts, CNN announced that the individual mandate had been struck down.
Discussion:
The Daily Beast, The Moderate Voice, New York Magazine and Wonkette
New York Times:
Victory for Obama, but Ruling Limits Medicaid Provision — WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld most of President Obama's health care overhaul law, saying it was authorized by Congress's power to levy taxes. The vote was 5 to 4, with Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. joining the court's four more liberal members.
Discussion:
The Huffington Post, The Caucus, Reuters, Politico, Bloomberg, FiveThirtyEight, SCOTUSblog, Washington Post, National Review, The New Republic, American Power, The Apothecary, Ross Douthat, Georgia Tipsheet, The Week, No More Mister Nice Blog, KevinMD.com, The Confluence and Prairie Weather
Jonathan Chait / New York Magazine:
John Roberts Saves Us All — We will never complain about you again. Until next term. — Two fears have hovered over American liberals since the legal case against the Affordable Care Act began wending its way through the legal system. The first was a fear that conservatives would succeed …
Discussion:
Washington Post, Slate, BuzzFeed and Hit & Run
msnbc.com:
Supreme Court upholds health care law — Supporters of the Affordable Healthcare Act gather in front of the Supreme Court before the court's announcement of the legality of the law in Washington. — In a dramatic victory for President Barack Obama, the Supreme Court upheld …
Discussion:
TBogg, The Other McCain, The Political Carnival, Fox News, CANNONFIRE, Balloon Juice and Towleroad News #gay
Adam Winkler / The Huffington Post:
The Roberts Court is Born — Supreme Court , Affordable Care Act , Anthony Kennedy , John Roberts , Commerce Clause , Politics News — Today's Supreme Court is often referred to as Anthony Kennedy's Court. Although Kennedy is the swing justice who usually casts the deciding vote in close cases …
Discussion:
ABCNEWS, The Week, SCOTUSblog, The Maddow Blog, Election Law Blog, ACS Blog, Hit & Run, Democracy in America and Guardian
Rand Paul:
Sen. Paul Statement on Obamacare Ruling
Sen. Paul Statement on Obamacare Ruling
Discussion:
ThinkProgress, Crooks and Liars, Runnin' Scared, Mediaite, Indecision Forever and The Raw Story
Sarah Kliff / Washington Post:
For SCOTUSblog, one goal: ‘Beat everybody’ and break news of health-care ruling
For SCOTUSblog, one goal: ‘Beat everybody’ and break news of health-care ruling
Discussion:
SCOTUSblog, FishbowlDC, JIMROMENESKO.COM, Taylor Marsh, Poynter, Capital Tonight, Mashable!, Betsy's Page, Washington Wire and The Hill, more at Mediagazer »
Paul Bedard / Washington Examiner:
GOP governors vow to ignore Obamacare
GOP governors vow to ignore Obamacare
Discussion:
Weasel Zippers and The Lonely Conservative
Robert Barnes / Washington Post:
Supreme Court to rule Thursday on health-care law
Supreme Court to rule Thursday on health-care law
Discussion:
CNN, Outside the Beltway, A Blog For All, The Democratic Daily, Weasel Zippers, News Desk and Greg's Opinion
CNN:
Romney reacts to health care ruling, renews repeal pledge
Romney reacts to health care ruling, renews repeal pledge
Discussion:
Politico, Outside the Beltway and ABCNEWS
Michael Hastings / BuzzFeed:
CNN News Staffers Revolt Over Blown Coverage
CNN News Staffers Revolt Over Blown Coverage
Discussion:
Business Insider, The Daily Caller, theGrio, Gawker, American Spectator and The Daily Dish, more at Mediagazer »
usccb.org:
Bishops Renew Plea To Congress And Administration To Repair Affordable Care Act
Bishops Renew Plea To Congress And Administration To Repair Affordable Care Act
Discussion:
Washington Wire, BuzzFeed and Daily Kos
The White House:
The Affordable Care Act is helping millions of Americans like you.
The Affordable Care Act is helping millions of Americans like you.
Discussion:
Towleroad News #gay, slacktivist, The Maddow Blog and Human Rights Campaign Blog
Sam Baker / The Hill:
Supreme Court backs healthcare law in vindication for Obama
Supreme Court backs healthcare law in vindication for Obama
Discussion:
Politico, The Hill, Power Line, Politicker, Wake up America and Alan Colmes' Liberaland
Scott Lemieux / Lawyers, Guns & Money:
The Radicalism (And Hackery) of the Health Care Cases Dissenters
The Radicalism (And Hackery) of the Health Care Cases Dissenters
Discussion:
American Prospect, Firedoglake, Brad DeLong, law.cornell.edu, The Huffington Post and US Politics
Jake Tapper / ABCNEWS:
POTUS First Learned Erroneous News on Court Decision from Cable TV
POTUS First Learned Erroneous News on Court Decision from Cable TV
Discussion:
Mediaite, Washington Wire, CNN, TVNewser, The Stranger … and Guardian
Matthew Yglesias / Slate:
Medicaid and the ACA: What's the Deal?
Medicaid and the ACA: What's the Deal?
Discussion:
ThinkProgress, L.A. NOW, The Maddow Blog, Wonkette and Washington Post
Wall Street Journal:
Henninger: The President That Time Forgot
Henninger: The President That Time Forgot
Discussion:
The Glittering Eye and The Daily Caller
Josh Levs / CNN:
What the health care ruling means to you
What the health care ruling means to you
Discussion:
This Just In, WJLA-TV, NO QUARTER, Informed Comment and ABCNEWS
David Frum / The Daily Beast:
Repeal Is a Fantasy — Republican presidential candidate Mitt …
Repeal Is a Fantasy — Republican presidential candidate Mitt …
Discussion:
News Desk, Washington Times, Outside the Beltway, The Daily Caller and The PJ Tatler
Paul Waldman / American Prospect:
Republicans Will Soon Stop Talking about Health Care
Republicans Will Soon Stop Talking about Health Care
Discussion:
RedState
Sahil Kapur / tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com:
TPMDC — Republicans Drop Talk Of Health Care ‘Replace’ — For Now
TPMDC — Republicans Drop Talk Of Health Care ‘Replace’ — For Now
Discussion:
The Atlantic Wire, Washington Post, Politico, Examiner and Daily Kos
Mike Dorning / Bloomberg:
Obama'S Legacy At Risk After Winning Health-Care Fight
Zeke Miller / BuzzFeed:
CNN Gets ObamaCare Decision Wrong
Bloomberg:
Do Republicans Really Want Universal Health Care?
Do Republicans Really Want Universal Health Care?
Discussion:
Washington Post, PERRspectives, Washington Monthly, The Maddow Blog and Politico
CNN:
Obama: Supreme Court decision is a ‘victory’
Obama: Supreme Court decision is a ‘victory’
Discussion:
Politico, ABCNEWS, Washington Post, Outside the Beltway, Power Line and The Hill
Amy Howe / SCOTUSblog:
The mandate is constitutional: In Plain English
The mandate is constitutional: In Plain English
Discussion:
Legal Theory Blog, JustOneMinute and Alas, a Blog
Alex Alvarez / Mediaite:
Fox News Releases Statement After Initially Reporting Individual Mandate Was ‘Gone’
Fox News Releases Statement After Initially Reporting Individual Mandate Was ‘Gone’
Discussion:
Little Green Footballs and Poynter, more at Mediagazer »
David Bernstein / The Volokh Conspiracy:
Was Scalia's Dissent Originally a Majority Opinion? — Scalia's dissent, at least on first quick perusal, reads like it was originally written as a majority opinion (in particular, he consistently refers to Justice Ginsburg's opinion as “The Dissent"). Back in May, there were rumors floating …
BuzzFeed:
People Who Say They're Moving To Canada Because Of ObamaCare — I'm sure they'll like the healthcare just fine there. (via https:) — Dave Stopera — a few minutes ago — 24 responses
Discussion:
World Now, AllThingsD, Truth Wins Out, The Stranger … and Daily Kos
Daniel Halper / Weekly Standard:
Romney: 'If We Want to Get Rid of Obamacare, We're Going to Have to Replace President Obama' — Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney reacted to the Supreme Court's Obamacare decision by saying that, “if we want to get rid of Obamacare, we're going to have to replace President Obama.”
Discussion:
Belmont Club, Hot Air, The Jawa Report and Washington Examiner
RELATED:
Maggie Haberman / Politico:
Romney: I'll repeal it — Via POLITICO's Ginger Gibson …
Romney: I'll repeal it — Via POLITICO's Ginger Gibson …
Discussion:
ABCNEWS
Andrew Kaczynski / BuzzFeed:
Romney In 2007: The Indvididual Mandate Is “Ultimate Conservatism”
DealBook:
JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion — Losses on JPMorgan Chase's bungled trade could total as much as $9 billion, far exceeding earlier public estimates, according to people who have been briefed on the situation. — When Jamie Dimon, the bank's chief executive …
Tom Curry / msnbc.com:
SCOTUS strikes down Stolen Valor Act — The Supreme Court on Thursday struck down a federal law called the Stolen Valor Act which prohibits a person from falsely claiming that he has been awarded a military honor. — The case involved Xavier Alvarez who was an elected member …
Discussion:
Washington Post and Maggie's Farm
RELATED:
Tejinder Singh / SCOTUSblog:
Court Holds Stolen Valor Act unconstitutional, dismisses First American Financial v. Edwards
Court Holds Stolen Valor Act unconstitutional, dismisses First American Financial v. Edwards
Discussion:
Above the Law, Hot Air, Hit & Run and Hullabaloo
Susan Page / USA Today:
‘Today’ co-host Ann Curry will bid farewell today — Ann Curry's voice chokes when she talks about saying goodbye this morning on NBC's Today show, years earlier than she had hoped. — It's “going to be a bit of a tough day,” she told USA TODAY in a 40-minute phone interview Wednesday …
Discussion:
Mediaite, FishbowlDC, Colorlines, Media Decoder, New York Magazine, TVNewser, Gawker, PopWatch, Poynter, Mashable! and TMZ.com, more at Mediagazer »